Red Dwarf S01E04 Waiting for God // Series 1 (1988) Review Part 4

A well directed shot from the episode

Context for those unfamiliar with Red Dwarf (Spoilers for Episode 1 of the show)

Dave Lister is the last man alive. He’s living in the mining ship “Red Dwarf” with a Hologram of his dead roommate, Rimmer; a member of a species of evolved cats, “The Cat”; and a computer on the ship, Holly. Lister crushes on a deceased member of the crew, Kristine Kochanski.

I was glad to see this episode would be covering the religious aspect of the show. Sadly, it’s not too in depth, but even what we get is nice. The episode starts with Holly revealing to the audience that Lister faked the exam that he took last episode. He follows this up with “That gives you some idea of how truly exciting some days can be around here.” I like the cheeky way of advertising the show with that line. The exam or Lister’s status aren’t brought up again in this episode or the rest of series 1. Why not try to fit the reveal on the end of last episode instead of having it in this one? It would be better to just not bring it up at all.

Rimmer’s obsessive and retentive ways continue to be shown. He so much wants to look good for who knows? We learn he hangs his underwear on coat hangers. Rimmer sees a space pod of unknown origins come by the ship. He’s more or less confident it’s aliens who can give him a body, something he’s wanted recurringly throughout the show. Rimmer wants to talk to someone about the pod so badly, he wakes up Lister. When Lister wears one of Rimmer’s shirts, Rimmer makes a fuss, but Lister is nice enough to offer it back. Holly tells Lister it’s a garbage pod, but they both think it’d be funny to not tell Rimmer. This is interesting to me as Holly’s a computer. We’ve seen a few times where he made jokes.

Speaking of Lister, he learns from a cat book about some of the complexities of the religion around him. The cats even fought in a war over it. There’s a joke about death when we learn the war was fought over the color of a hat Lister would wear in the business he dreams of having. Holly says most of the cats left Red Dwarf with Lister’s laundry list, thinking it was directions to the “promised land”. The God plot stops for a bit, then resumes with Lister telling Rimmer he doesn’t want to be God. Rimmer says he would like to be God. That’s a nice, quick way of showing more of Rimmer’s complex. Lister feels bad for indirectly hurting the cats, but Rimmer is more focused on the pod. Rimmer has poorly placed faith, just like the cats. Rimmer’s trying to decipher useless info on the pod, like how the cats tried to decipher Lister’s things and learn what they mean. We get good acting from Lister when he speaks of wishing he could change what happened.

SPOILERS

Finally, a story for the Cat. For some reason, he goes to visit an old cat priest that’s dying. The Cat just wants to talk about himself. He respects the priest as much as anyone else, not much. The priest gives a frustrating exposition dump. He describes himself, he’s a priest who just stopped believing in God. Lister finds the Cat and the priest and comforts the priest the best he can. He acts like how he was described, as God. The priest said that when the cats left for the promised land, the sick and the lame were left behind. The priest was one of them. It’s a bit annoying that the priest is literally just explaining everything, but what he’s saying is interesting, so it’s forgivable. The priest, having met God, says this is the happiest day of his life and he dies right there. We get more good acting with Lister when he has a disturbed look on his face.

I find it interesting the Cat was quiet during the priest and Lister’s conversation. This was probably an oversight by the writers. Perhaps the character wanted to be respectful? Note that in Episode 1, the Cat said “no one” believed in the religion being true. The Cat was born after the cats left. It makes sense that when the cats left behind the ill, the ill would not believe in the religion as the religious were not respectful to them. Thus, they wouldn’t teach it as true to future generations. Even the priest lost his faith. There’s a nice parallel between the religion plot and Rimmer’s plot. The priest regains his faith while Rimmer loses it upon discovering the truth behind the pod.

OVERVIEW

It was good that we finally got a story for the Cat, even though it mostly followed Lister. The Cat infamously doesn’t get storylines, so you got to take what you can get. This episode stayed focused on its core idea, which had foreshadowing earlier in the series, but Lister and Rimmer still got time to interact. This one gets you thinking about religion, at least a little. It’s intelligently thought out and creative. The priest’s guest actor, Noel Coleman, was good in the role. This is probably the first great episode, though “Balance of Power” was pretty good, and the second best of series 1…

The Mike & Micky Show Live (2020 album) Review

A frame from the “Daydream Believer” music video, sung by Davy Jones (second from left)

For the past year (has it been so long? So short?!) I’ve listened to and enjoyed the albums of the Monkees. Here is their newest live album and possibly their very last album. It might seem pointless to make a new album, seeing as 50% of the band, Davy Jones and Peter Tork, are sadly deceased. It’s also noteworthy as Michael Nesmith was the Monkee least involved with the Monkees. He was often entirely absent from tours. After the quartet played in the mid-90’s, he would not return until 2012, sadly after Davy Jones had passed. He’s progressively played more since then and here, he certainly isn’t absent from the album. He most likely features on all of this album’s songs.

As a guitarist for most of his life, Nesmith probably fills all the lead guitar roles. It sounds so good to hear him and Micky banter. For a few tracks, they’ll talk to the audience briefly before singing a song. Both Nesmith and Micky Dolenz seem to be having the time of their lives playing these tunes. There’s real excitement in their voices. It’s quite wholesome and heartwarming hearing Nez say he’s never enjoyed working with someone more than Micky Dolenz.

There’s no new songs here, it’s all the old favorites that Monkees fans have probably heard several times. There’s no complaints from me there. Most of these songs sound very good. Even the bad ones, like “Mary, Mary” have more spirit and energy here than on their original album counterparts. These songs sound less like pop songs than initially. Maybe that’s because they’re sung live or because they’ve been rehearsed a million times. That more lively and consistent sound gives this album its flavor. Two of my favorites from this album are “The Door Into Summer” and “A Little Bit Me, A Little Bit You”. Those two, as well as many other tracks on this album, play with the ambiance of the scene. The instruments and singing fill the space and make a spectacle. Songs like “Pleasant Valley Sunday” and “Tapioca Tundra” are more poetic lyrically and are sung more on the quiet side than many others. The choice of instruments and how they’re used sounds methodical.

Not all of the songs are improved. A common problem I’ve had with the Monkees’ sound once they’ve gotten older is that the songs seem like they’re written for guys in their twenties. When they’re singing them in their fifties, sixties, seventies they just don’t sound right. A key example is “(Theme From) The Monkees”, which includes the line “We’re the young generation…” Fortunately, that song’s absent. I’ve never liked it much anyway. Songs that are present here, like “[I’m Not Your] Steppin’ Stone”, which is about a gold digger who is perturbing the singer and “Last Train To Clarksville”, which is about a soldier going to war; don’t make much sense with older voices.

Generally, the best songs don’t sound as good as they’re not recreated in the right way. I always loved the timpani in “Randy Scouse Git”, but it’s absent here. “The Girl I Knew Somewhere” originally had Nesmith on backing vocals, but now he’s not. It’s not like he was elsewhere at the time. A lot of the songs are performed slower and/or with certain instruments or scenes missing. Some songs are improved with these changes. “Papa Gene’s Blues” is a song that is popular with fans, but I never really liked. Here, Micky and Mike talk briefly, then it’s performed with a more raw sound than previously. There’s fewer instruments and a more simplistic composition. Micky participates with backing vocals which make the song sound much better. Multiple vocalists often improve the sound by adding a bit of weight to the piece. Many tracks feature female backup singers. They were very good. I was surprised by how much they complimented the songs. The more relaxed and stripped back style works with songs like “Sunny Girlfriend” and “Goin’ Down” as well. Because of pronunciations of words and instrument choices, songs like “Goin’ Down” and “For Pete’s Sake” made more sense to me.

The final four tracks could be called this album’s finale. At least to me, they have a grand feeling to them. “[I’m Not Your] Steppin’ Stone” was the last track on side A of More of the Monkees. Here, it’s the first of the last four. It emphasizes this album’s playful style by knowing it’s a bit silly, but the more wild and loud sound bring it to life. There is a bit of power in the performance of the instrumentalists. Next up is the band’s second most famous song, “Daydream Believer”. Daydream’s singer, Davy Jones, passing was quite hard on the many fans of the Monkees. This album’s version was quite sweet and humble. Micky sings most of the song, then says “It’s your turn…” to the audience. The audience sings the chorus and Micky jumps back in and ties it all off. This version of the song seems like an attempt to bring back Davy’s spirit and influence. The things people love about him simmer and ring. He was the one with the smile. He was the frontman. He was the image of the group. On an album by the Clash, one song called “We Are the Clash” was partially sung by a crowd that shouted “We Are the Clash!” That band’s frontman, Joe Strummer, said the message of the song was to say that the fans were the Clash. I interpret this version of “Daydream Believer” similarly. The fans are important to the product. We come together to go to concerts, listen to albums, and fill the hole that formed when Davy died. This song is like a finale to Davy. It encompasses many of his best qualities, his humility and heart.

It was a bummer to me that the best Monkees albums, The Monkees Present, was only represented by one song, but it’s one of my favorite Monkees songs and it’s the most liked song on Present. “Listen To The Band” rocks. It continues the spirit of Steppin’ Stone with its loud, orchestral style and energized lyrics and singing. Even on the original studio album, it appeared as though the song was trying to imitate a live sound. It works perfectly well as the real thing. The song is mainly about getting people lively. I always love the part when Nesmith yells “Listen to the Band!” and the instruments start roaring. This one is Nez’ finale. It has all the things that work about his songs. There’s a story and performance to them. Now it’s time for Micky’s finale. This song is the band’s most famous and it ends the album very well. It’s kind of strange that “I’m A Believer” works as well as it does. It’s just a love song on paper, but it plays like a little ballad in how it’s performed. This one gets the crowd going and it leaves you on a good feeling. This is the same on its original album, More of the Monkees. This was the last song on that album too. Some of Micky’s wordless vocals in the piece help emphasize the love he has for the girl in the song. The instruments flesh out the environment and tone of the piece. The song ends in finality for the album and possibly the Monkees’ discography as a whole. Who knows?

The Monkees have nothing left to prove. They’ve compiled a lot of their hits together and made a great show with them. None of these songs sound bad and some are pretty good. What’s next for the band? I can’t be sure, but it’ll surely be fun to sit back and see.